Homeowners insurance protects individuals and families from financial losses due to property damage, theft, or liability claims. Required by most mortgage lenders, this coverage supports both household financial security and housing market stability. A recent analysis of insurance premium prices across Delaware, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania reveals significant increases from December 2021 to June 2025. After adjusting for inflation, average premiums rose 25.4 percent in Delaware, 26.1 percent in New Jersey, and 28.9 percent in Pennsylvania. These increases substantially outpaced home price appreciation in both Pennsylvania and Delaware during the same period.
Studies point to several factors contributing to rising costs, including more frequent and severe weather events, higher construction and labor expenses, and increased reinsurance costs as global insurers respond to elevated risk exposure.
This analysis revealed notable geographic disparities. Properties in low- to moderate-income neighborhoods experienced larger premium rate increases compared with middle- and upper-income areas across all three states. Premium rates — the cost per $1,000 of coverage — are consistently higher in lower-income neighborhoods, communities of color, and areas with elevated disaster risk.
Rising insurance costs appear linked to mortgage payment difficulties. Properties with larger premium increases showed higher rates of mortgage delinquency across all three states, although whether premiums directly cause delinquency requires further investigation.
These findings highlight insurance affordability as an emerging challenge in housing markets. For households already dedicating significant income to housing expenses, rapidly rising premiums can strain budgets and potentially threaten homeownership stability. The disproportionate impact on lower-income neighborhoods raises important questions about equitable access to affordable coverage.
View the Full Brief